RARE HORROR VINYL: Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark LP, Alvin Schwartz 1986
  $   565

 


$ 565 Sold For
Sep 2, 2026 Sold Date
Aug 26, 2026 Start Date
3   Number Of Bids
  USA Country Of Seller
eBay Auctioned at
 
save auction  

Description

This is an incredibly rare vinyl record, 1986’s Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark by Alvin Schwartz, read by George S. Irving. Many consider this the holy grail of horror vinyl. 
Please see my photos & video for details. Record is in excellent condition with no visible scratches or marks. The sleeve has some writing & circled tracks on the back, but the front is in excellent condition for display. 
This is so rare you won’t find it on eBay; the last one listed here sold for over $400 with 30+ bids. I sell all my items for charity. Every dollar made from this record will be donated to The Sharing Center, Seminole County’s largest free food pantry and homeless resource center. Check my other listings for more cool finds.
*Edit: We'll be packing the vinyl outside of the sleeve and packed in a custom wood box. It will arrive to you pristine.


price rating


My Recently Viewed Auctions

NANCY SINATRA +2 @ LEE HAZELWOOD RED/ORANGE WAX KOREA? NANCY SINATRA +2 @ LEE HAZELWOOD RED/ORANGE WAX KOREA? / $ 115
Pico 1002 Latin 78 RPM rare L.A. label Imploracion, Confesion, Mujer Paseada E- Pico 1002 Latin 78 RPM rare L.A. label Imploracion, Confesion, Mujer Paseada E- / $ 20
LIFE IS STRANGE: TRUE COLORS (SOUNDTRACK) (TRANSLUCENT YELLOW VINYL) NEW VINYL R LIFE IS STRANGE: TRUE COLORS (SOUNDTRACK) (TRANSLUCENT YELLOW VINYL) NEW VINYL R / $ 69
Rare Country LP - Jimmie Skinner - The Kentucky Colonel - Starday # SLP 240 Rare Country LP - Jimmie Skinner - The Kentucky Colonel - Starday # SLP 240 / $ 22
Allen,Tony / Masekela,Hugh - Rejoice [New Vinyl LP] Special Ed Allen,Tony / Masekela,Hugh - Rejoice [New Vinyl LP] Special Ed / $ 23
Cerron - 3 - Supernature - Used Vinyl Record - N7751z Cerron - 3 - Supernature - Used Vinyl Record - N7751z / $ 30
The Smiths Rank Alternative Rock Vinyl Album Gatefold 1986 Sire Records The Smiths Rank Alternative Rock Vinyl Album Gatefold 1986 Sire Records / $ 32
Minus The Bear - Highly Refined Pirates Vinyl, LP, Album, Limited Edition, Remas Minus The Bear - Highly Refined Pirates Vinyl, LP, Album, Limited Edition, Remas / $ 22
DEBONAIRES - Maske 804 - Every Other Day - DOO-WOP 45 DEBONAIRES - Maske 804 - Every Other Day - DOO-WOP 45 / $ 30
Dan Fogelberg & Tim Weisberg Dan Fogelberg & Tim Weisberg "Twin Sons..." Pristine NEVER PLAYED MasterSound LP / $ 23
RCA Living Stereo 2378 Schubert Death & Maiden Julliard RCA Living Stereo 2378 Schubert Death & Maiden Julliard / $ 28
SHAWN ELLIOTT: The Sidewinder / Hello Heartache, Goodbye Love 45 (dj, jazzy Mod SHAWN ELLIOTT: The Sidewinder / Hello Heartache, Goodbye Love 45 (dj, jazzy Mod / $ 25
AND ALSO THE TREES THE MILLPOND YEARS LP ORIGINAL VINYL VG++ AND ALSO THE TREES THE MILLPOND YEARS LP ORIGINAL VINYL VG++ / $ 28
KAREN ELSON ghost who walks 7 KAREN ELSON ghost who walks 7" tri color third man / $ 161
FUSE ?– Fuse LP BN 26502 / 1970 Rock Hard Rock VG++ Cheap Trick FUSE ?– Fuse LP BN 26502 / 1970 Rock Hard Rock VG++ Cheap Trick / $ 25
JOHN COLTRANE / ARCHIE SHEPP New Thing At Newport IMPULSE JOHN COLTRANE / ARCHIE SHEPP New Thing At Newport IMPULSE / $ 25
Eliahu Inbal / MAHLER SYMPHONY No.6 & 10 - Japan 2LP w/OBI PCM Audiophile Eliahu Inbal / MAHLER SYMPHONY No.6 & 10 - Japan 2LP w/OBI PCM Audiophile / $ 80
TYPE O NEGATIVE 'Bloody Kisses' 2018 NEW Import 2-LP 180 Gram Pressing TYPE O NEGATIVE 'Bloody Kisses' 2018 NEW Import 2-LP 180 Gram Pressing / $ 25
Rage Against The Machine Live At the Grand Olympic Auditorium 180g 2LP MINT NEW Rage Against The Machine Live At the Grand Olympic Auditorium 180g 2LP MINT NEW / $ 30
SHEFFIELD LAB DIRECT TO DISC LP THE DRUM RECORD JIM KELTNER AUDIOPHILE /584 SHEFFIELD LAB DIRECT TO DISC LP THE DRUM RECORD JIM KELTNER AUDIOPHILE /584 / $ 27
BONNIE DOBSON She's Like A Swallow 1961 Prestige FOLK BONNIE DOBSON She's Like A Swallow 1961 Prestige FOLK / $ 28
RARE NORTHERN SOUL 45/ SAM DEES RARE NORTHERN SOUL 45/ SAM DEES "SOUL SISTER" NEAR MINT HEAR / $ 190
THE CLASH Birmingham's Burning LP vinyl JOE STRUMMER THE CLASH Birmingham's Burning LP vinyl JOE STRUMMER / $ 35
New Give Up The Ghost Lp, American Nightmare, Terror, First Blood, Cursed New Give Up The Ghost Lp, American Nightmare, Terror, First Blood, Cursed / $ 25
Brad - United We Stand Vinyl Lp Brad - United We Stand Vinyl Lp / $ 65
C499 Bach Harpsichord Concertos Leonhardt 5LP Telefunken 6.35049 FX Stereo C499 Bach Harpsichord Concertos Leonhardt 5LP Telefunken 6.35049 FX Stereo / $ 25
ANITA O'DAY Swing Rodgers and Hart '60 VERVE 1st Press DG ORIG JAZZ LP RARE NMin ANITA O'DAY Swing Rodgers and Hart '60 VERVE 1st Press DG ORIG JAZZ LP RARE NMin / $ 21
Bread – The Best Of Bread (Elektra 75) - Misty-White *NEW RECORD LP VINYL INDIE Bread – The Best Of Bread (Elektra 75) - Misty-White *NEW RECORD LP VINYL INDIE / $ 25
ID72z - Roger Waters - Pros Cons Of New Y - vinyl LP - New ID72z - Roger Waters - Pros Cons Of New Y - vinyl LP - New / $ 32
The Eathopians, Fire A Mus Mus Tail, CRAB 2,1968, Crab, Vinyl, 7 The Eathopians, Fire A Mus Mus Tail, CRAB 2,1968, Crab, Vinyl, 7", 45 RPM, EX+ / $ 78
Sacrilegio LP Mexican Heavy Power Metal Mexico luzbel Sacrilegio LP Mexican Heavy Power Metal Mexico luzbel / $ 27
Green Day-`Kerplunk (120g Vinyl W/1 7`` Single)` VINYL LP NEW Green Day-`Kerplunk (120g Vinyl W/1 7`` Single)` VINYL LP NEW / $ 23
FRANK ZAPPA MOTHERS OF INVENTION - Ruben & The Jets VERVE Vinyl LP Record FRANK ZAPPA MOTHERS OF INVENTION - Ruben & The Jets VERVE Vinyl LP Record / $ 20